Before you can man up, you’ve got to calm down

rikki-tedxwarwick4I guess now I’ve opened my mind to something new, I find myself needing to write yet another gender-related post. Just like the last one, I’ve gone through several drafts and re-writes before actually settling on something. The last draft theorised about whether the gender binary was actually obsolete and unimportant, until I watched this TEDx talk by Rikki Arundel about how gender is important. Watching it reinforced some of the points I was making, but also showed me how I was writing from a personal perspective. I’m still learning about gender identities and gender politics, yet Rikki actually lives it. On my website, I’ve sounded out theories and adopted points of view based on what I knew at the time of writing, but I’m always willing to listen to and learn from other people’s experiences.

Although, on paper, our headlines would appear to be at odds with each other, I was actually approaching my post from a different angle so the two were complementary: gender is important emotionally, but it shouldn’t be important socially.

ymbkz_05
Nobody calls me “chicken”

Coupled with a post I read on Paging Dr. Nerdlove about defining modern masculinity, the video highlighted just how little flexibility the male sex has in terms of their gender identity and expression and how aggressively it’s policed. Rikki demonstrated this by showing that, in terms of clothing, Women can buy their clothes from Burton’s (a UK Menswear store) and very few would even notice. If a man shopped next door at Dorothy Perkins, he’s putting himself at risk of hatred, humiliation and even violence for breaking the unwritten “rules” of masculinity. Male culture is beset with bullying and fear as a means of policing conformity; fear is also used to maintain the masculine trait of fearlessness – just think of the effects words like “wuss”, “chicken” and “pansy” have.

10499861_2
Your wife’s going to kill you, but look on the bright side: at least Needles doesn’t think you’re a chicken.

We’re afraid of appearing afraid, so we overcompensate by ramping up the “bravery” (I use inverted commas as this so-called bravery likely involves reckless stupidity) and putting ourselves at far greater risk just to prove a point.These “brave” men are really just so insecure and fragile in their identity, they cannot stand up for themselves against even mild peer pressure.

 

When I opined about the unimportance of gender, I overlooked something important. When you’re locked into a culture where gender is so aggressively policed and you’re not strong enough to give it the finger, your gender expression is a means of survival. I can’t begin to understand what trans people have to go through just to feel comfortable with themselves, something cis people take for granted, but with the personal, social and political turmoil they’d have to face, I can understand why some would become so emotionally attached and protective of the gender identity they’ve worked so hard for.

But despite our emotional attachment to gender, the social attachment should be minuscule at most. This week, I have to do a compliance course for my new employer, and the handbook I was given in advance had a whole section on conduct and discrimination. It was likely the most thorough anti-discrimination policy I’ve ever read. To put it simply, if I openly discriminate against anyone on the grounds of race, colour, sex, age, nationality, religion, sexuality, gender identity or gender expression… I stand a very good chance of getting sacked. This is coming from a major, global organisation. It’s not a radical policy either – every organisation I’ve worked for, whether it be local, national or global, has had a pretty strict anti-discrimination policy. This is why I feel gender should not be important socially – at work, we are required to collaborate and cooperate with each other, so one’s gender is of less importance than one’s skills, abilities, personality and behaviour.

If that’s how we’re expected to behave inside work, what’s so different about behaving that way outside work? What’s so difficult about respecting one’s individuality, or just simply leaving them alone?

alpha-male-traits-failure

I feel Dr. Nerdlove is correct when they say that some men need to calm down, work on their insecurities and become stronger in a more constructive way though being less quick to anger. While I’m not exactly a prime example of manliness on the outside, I am probably stronger in myself than some of the more “alpha” males. I’m not frightened of or threatened by people who are different to me – at worst, I’m respectfully curious. I’m not concerned about other people’s opinions of me – an opinion is not a fact, and is more reflective of the person making it than it is of me. Most importantly, words are just words. Call me whatever you like – even seemingly insulting names like “lady boy” or “batty man” – just please excuse me if I completely ignore you.

That’s my brand of strength and bravery: brave enough to break the norm, and strong enough to handle the criticism that follows.

 

Advertisements

4 thoughts on “Before you can man up, you’ve got to calm down

  1. I’ve always hated terms like “man up” I think we should just abandon gender roles anyway. I’m sure much of male depression is caused by men feeling like they can’t talk about their issues, or bave to “man up”. And anyway, as for Marty, he learned not to react when someone called him “chicken” in the end

    Like

    1. I agree totally. I was a lot like that several years ago, feeling like I had to “be a man”, bottle all my emotions up and just get on with it – it’s a very vicious spiral. I read a interesting article earlier this afternoon which theorised that, a century ago, men were expected to become these dominating, emotionally-detached sacks of homophobia as a means of keeping the family unit intact, ensuring the constant production of babies to become future factory labour and cannon fodder. While that’s completely redundant with how low infant mortality rates are today in comparison, it’s as if some old habits die hard.

      And as for Marty, a little green man told him that hate leads to anger, anger leads to fear and fear leads to the dark side. Or am I thinking of the wrong movie? 🙂

      Liked by 1 person

      1. It’s common sense, IMO. I wouldn’t even need to look at studies to prove it.

        I think you’ve got your 80’s movies mixed up lol. I think it’s because stereotypical “male” behavior got him nowhere…it essentially ruined his life in BTF2, because his future self ruined his guitar playing hand in a car accident because Needles called him “chicken”

        It’s a well known fact that male depression is a huge problem and male suicide rates are considerably higher. Males are almost encouraged NOT to talk about their problems or show any kind of emotion, so no wonder. A man falls apart when his wife or girlfriend leaves because he relies on her so much for support. Men don’t seem to discuss their feelings among themselves like women do. I can’t say I fully understand it, even being trans and having existed as a male once. It seemed so alien to me.

        But I respect men who are open with their feelings and don’t buy into “boys don’t cry” or “man up”. Such men are men that I would be friends with or date, rather than the robotic macho “it’s gay to show feelings” kind.

        Liked by 1 person

  2. It is impossibly hard on men, I agree. I love it when I see a man rocking the nail polish or wearing a sarong at the beach – they’re little things but I suspect they take a great deal of bravery. My daughter (ironically she was born with a boy’s body) holds strong views of gender roles. For instance she will tell her brother he can’t wear a dress because he’s a boy. Her brother, father and I gently remind her that clothing doesn’t define a person, anyone can wear a dress or a tuxedo… It facinates me that she says these things, having been free to express her feminine self long before we understood she was transgender.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s